Nuance, Sex and Family: The Stuff of Great Villains

Great villains don’t see themselves as villains. This moral blind spot not only enables their bad ass ways but also dangles a nuanced humanity–accessible actions that have us believing in their potential for redemption–that makes them so downright scary.

Great villains have:

  • Focus and purpose—they are on a mission, even if we don’t agree with it.
  • Leadership and fierce intellect—while there are many lone villains out there, I like those that come as part of a pack. Their ability to motivate their people, care for them even if that care is twisted reveals that nuanced humanity.
  • Beauty and Seductiveness—their words, mannerisms, looks, intellect, all would be drop dead sexy if their bad wasn’t so truly bad.  They tempt us using our weaknesses as bait.

I’ve got two favorites—one male, one female.  Let’s start with Hans Gruber, played to perfection by Alan Rickman, in the film Die Hard.

When he glides off the elevator in a custom-tailored, Savile Row suit, followed by a horde of to-die-for bad boys masquerading as terrorists to execute the ultimate burglary, Hans had me at:  “I could talk about men’s fashion and industrialization all day but I’m afraid work must intrude .” The British accent upped him on the hot scale, and had him serving up dialogue in a way that made me swoon.

Witty, sophisticated, brilliant, I’d have gone for him big time if he didn’t have a ruthless penchant for killing innocent people.  Although he radiated heartlessness, he wrangled his pack as a true leader, stayed firm to his goals, perverse as they might be, and maintained a veneer of politeness when dealing with the hostages (even though he did ultimately plan on killing them all). Not a hair or etiquette out of place.

What really made Hans accessible was Alan Rickman’s performance.   In Rickman’s own words, Hans was not a villain.  And that is why he nailed the character—he  kept him human.

My favorite female bad ass is the Borg Queen (BQ) from Star Trek, played by Alice Krige in the movie First Contact and Susanna Thompson in the Star Trek Voyager series. BQ slinks into our world with the swagger of a seductress, catching Lt. Commander Data in her claws.  Take a peak:

BQ:       “Are you familiar with physical forms of pleasure?”
Data:    “If you are referring to sexuality, I am fully functional, programmed in multiple techniques.”
BQ:     “ How long since you’ve used them?”
Data:   “Eight years, seven months, 16 days, four minutes, 22—“
BQ:       “Far too long.”

If you haven’t seen the movie, yes, she kisses him and he kisses her back.  In addition to temptress, the  Borg leader prowls with the protectiveness of a mother tigress shielding her young.  Here’s a snippet from Endgame with Seven of Nine, a former Borg drone returned to humanity by Janeway and the Star Trek Voyager crew:

BQ:          “Seven of Nine, Tertiary Adjunct of Unimatrix 01. It’s been too long.”
Seven:  “What do you want?”
BQ:          “Do I need a reason to visit a friend?”
Seven:   “We’re not friends.”
BQ:          “No. We’re more than that. We’re family.”

She may not be human, but the humanity in that demeanor cannot be denied. With an emotional vein, not present in the drones she leads, she can be hated.  The Borg drones are victims, and can only elicit only our pity.

The Borg Queen as mother brings us closer to her and separates us from her entirely.  To protect her collective, her family, is to terminate us. What I love most about her villainy is that while  Picard and Data defeated her, only Captain Janeway, another mother guarding her family, could destroy her.   Like Ellen Ripley and the Alien Queen, it takes a mother to outmaneuver a mother.  An interesting twist when dealing with female baddies.

It’s that need for family and loyalty to achieve defined objectives that makes these villains great, and gives us a way to understand them even as we hate them.  That nuance haunts us because it reminds us that but for fate, we are not that far away from villainy as we sometimes like to think.

I’d love to hear from you.  What characteristics make up a great villain?  Do they differ between male and female baddies?


Sabrina Garie is on a journey to create the most kick-ass heroine in romance fiction. You can meet the first heroine in Fires of Justice at Elloras Cave, Amazon, and Barnes and Nobles.

About Sabrina Garie

Writer, reader, explorer, chauffeur (oops, I meant mom)

Posted on October 16, 2012, in Sabrina Garie and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. I don’t know what I can add to what you’ve already said. Unforgettable villians for me are the ones who truely believe their reasoning for their actions are sound. A villian is great when I can remember more about them than the hero/heroine in the story.
    suz2(at)cox(dot)net

  2. Completely agree. A ‘good’ villain has a complete belief in what he wants to achieve will change the world for the better. Even if he does it in a ruthless way, he knows his actions are justified. And yes, Rickman is fantastic in Die Hard!

  3. I have to agree with suzlyne – I think you pretty much covered everything in your post about villains – they do have to have an edge of humanity about them or they are over the top – while I think a good villain can have and exhibit humor – it needs to be tempered with the rest of his personality or it becomes over the top (ala Mr. Freeze in Batman). Great post.

  4. All I know is I love villains. The Borg Queen tops my list. She is one awesome villain. Great post, Sabrina!

  5. I’m still pouting that you snagged Hans before me, but I have to agree with you 100%. Great post!

  6. Thanks Danica. Hans is a keeper. I’ll hold back and let you get first pick on the dark villains. Deal!

  7. Reblogged this on Sabrina Garie and commented:

    And my last reblog (I promise), from my other blogging endeavor. Once Thanksgiving is over, I’ll be back on schedule. Have a Happy Thanksgiving! all.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: